A tankless heater fires only when you open a hot tap. It can last around 20 years and frees floor space, but the upfront cost is higher than a tank, so the math depends on how long you plan to stay.
Where the extra cost comes from
Gas tankless units draw far more fuel at full fire than a tank, so the gas line may need upsizing. Most need new stainless or PVC venting. Electric models can call for a larger electrical service. Those items, more than the heater itself, often decide whether the switch makes sense in Java, SD.
Questions to settle before you commit
- How many showers and appliances run at once? Flow rate in gallons per minute sets the unit size.
- How cold is the incoming water in winter? Colder water needs a larger unit for the same flow.
- Is the water hard? Scale builds up in the heat exchanger and cuts output.
Keeping it running
Plan on flushing the heat exchanger with a pump and vinegar or descaler through the service valves, often yearly where water is hard, and cleaning the inlet screen. Skipping this is the main reason tankless units need repairs early.
A plumber booked through Pipewise Plumbing can price a tankless unit and a new tank side by side, so you can compare the totals over the years you expect to own the house.